Reflections on Ethics 33
Morality Without Religion
by Joseph C. Sommer
This article is republished, with the permission of the author, from the web site Humanism by Joe. This site contains a number excellent of articles on Law, Government, Sex, Religion, and Humanism.
A charge often heard by Humanists is that without belief in God, there is no basis for morality and the result is a society in which "anything goes." Actually, most nonbelievers have strong foundations for living ethically.
As the great nineteenth-century agnostic Robert Ingersoll often explained, one basis for nontheistic morality is simply the idea of self-defense. Because nontheists do not want to be murdered, robbed, raped, or otherwise injured, they support laws prohibiting those types of harmful acts.
By the same token, their desire to be treated fairly, honestly, and respectfully leads them to advocate laws and rules of conduct that promote fair, honest, and respectful treatment of people.
In this manner, the idea of self-defense produces a just system of laws and social standards.
Another basis for nontheistic morality is the principle of enlightened self-interest. Under this principle, it makes perfectly good sense for a person to treat others kindly and helpfully. For the treatment will likely cause them to reciprocate with similar behavior, thereby increasing the person's happiness.
Conversely, if a person treats people selfishly and abusively, he will likely be worse off in the long run. Sooner or later, the victims will realize the injustice being done to them. The usual response is then to retaliate against, ostracize, or otherwise punish the wrongdoer.
And it is not just the victims who recognize the wrongdoer as a dangerous person who should be avoided. Those who witness or learn about the wrongdoing are likely to feel the same way.
For instance, some people have no qualms about telling friends or coworkers of how they cheated, lied to, or stole from others. When thoughtful persons hear this, they know that since the person was willing to mistreat others in the past, he will almost certainly mistreat them in the future if he perceives a similar benefit to be gained from the act.
As a result, they view the person as a threat and danger. If they are smart, they will not trust or associate with him. At the very least, they will not do so in situations offering him a chance to defraud or otherwise harm them.
In an work environment, the person's ability to obtain raises and promotions is thereby reduced. His continued employment may be jeopardized. And in his personal life, the ability to develop meaningful relationships is restricted.
Because of the possible undesirable consequences of mistreating others, it is not in a person's long-term interest to behave that way.
Emotional and Physical Benefits
Nontheistic morality is also promoted by recent research indicating a person's emotional and physical health can improve by performing good works. As explained in Allan Luks' book The Healing Power of Doing Good, science is revealing that helping others can produce many benefits for the helper.
The benefits include, but are not limited to, experiencing a "helper's high" involving an initial rush of good feelings followed by a longer-lasting period of emotional well-being. These benefits make sense in terms of human evolutionary history. Early societies that were able to develop compassion, altruism, and cooperation would have a competitive advantage over societies that did not.
Emotional benefits of being kind to others are similarly described in Dr. Richard Carlson's book Don't Sweat the Small Stuff. "Perhaps the greatest reason to practice random kindness is that it brings great contentment into your life," he says. "Each act of kindness rewards you with positive feelings and reminds you of the important aspects of life - service, kindness, and love."
Thomas Jefferson and Nontheistic Morality
Based on some of these reasons for behaving ethically, Thomas Jefferson assured his nephew Peter Carr that belief in God is not necessary for morality.
In a letter to the young man, Jefferson advised: "Fix Reason firmly in her seat . . . . Question with boldness even the existence of a God . . . . Do not be frightened from this enquiry by any fear of its consequences. If it end in a belief that there is no God, you will find incitements to virtue in the comfort and pleasantness you feel in its exercise and in the love of others which it will procure for you."
[For further information on this subject, please see the essay titled "Religion, Nontheism and Unethical Behavior."]